Podcast No. 3: Sign, Trade Doumit? Play Diaz, Jaramillo? What to Make of Lerud?
In the third episode of Pirate Revolution's podcast, hosts Cory Humes and Nicolas Lewis wrap up the blog's week-long focus on the team's catching depth by answering questions posed by Alan Smodic in his positional overview.
Will Ryan Doumit be around when this team is a winner? The CHONE projections for 2009 expect Doumit to take only 384 at-bats this season. Is his upside as a power-hitting catcher worth the risk of missed time due to injury, or should he be shopped to a contender who can capitalize on his skills in the short term? He might fit well with John Henry's Red Sox.
Is it too early to tell what kind of future Robinzon Diaz and Jason Jaramillo will have with the team? Their prospect status is dim, but they are young and cost-controlled for several seasons.
On the farm, only Steve Lerud and Andrew Walker seem likely to reach the major leagues some day. Was Lerud really deserving of a 40-man roster spot? The guys discuss Wilbur Miller's prospect profile and wonder what the future will hold for this pair.
Finally, the long-term free agent market is explored. Perhaps the catcher on the next division-winning Pirates team will have been signed as Pudge Rodriguez was by the 2004 Detroit Tigers.
- Maldonado Sparks Caracas' Comeback
- Dominican Season Ends With a Bang; Hernandez Gets Save #5
- Dock Ellis, RIP: The Edges
- Pirates close to extension with Doumit
- Saturday's Winter Leagues
- Belisario Gets a Save; Canadian Pitcher Signed
- Dock Ellis Dead at Age 63
- Pirates Amassing a History of White Flag Hurlers
Discussion
2 Comments on "Podcast No. 3: Sign, Trade Doumit? Play Diaz, Jaramillo? What to Make of Lerud?"
#1
Posted by rob, December 22, 2008 10:45 AM
Nice job, guys... nice professional sounding podcast by #3. And, you are spot on with Doumit. I do a player ranking system for fantasy baseball, and standard 5x5, minimum 300 ABs and 20 games played at the C position, yields Doumit the #2 ranking in all of baseball.
The Pirates don't need to shore up catching (at least offensively). They already have it.
#2
Posted by Cory Humes in reply to comment from rob, December 22, 2008 12:47 PM
Thanks, Rob.
I guess the problem lies in whether or not a player like Doumit is a luxury for a team like the Pirates. I'm not sure how you see him in 3-5 years, but I'm wary of injuries. I don't see the Pirates as being a competitive team in that timeframe, and so I'd prefer to trade at a high point.
The Pirates did something similar with Mike Gonzalez -- "a 70-win team doesn't need a lights-out closer" -- and sold high for Adam LaRoche. I think we got the best of that deal, and could follow a similar process in sending Doumit to a contender.












Leave a comment